Insurance Overview Experience People News + Views + Events With a team of 40 insurance lawyers and decades of collective experience, Field Law is one of the major insurance firms in Alberta and the Northwest Territories for many of North America’s leading insurers. In addition to our core practice dedicated to defending insurance claims, Field Law has extensive experience preparing coverage opinions and pursuing subrogated claims on behalf of multinational and local insurers.
In Western Canada, circumstances can – and often do – change in the blink of an eye. We have a passion for the insurance industry that drives us to help clients mobilize and respond to these frequent changes quickly and effectively. Some of our lawyers have previously worked in-house for insurers. This translates into an understanding of industry trends and operations, billing protocols and reporting practices which helps support our ability to provide collaborative and timely solutions when our clients are most vulnerable.
The longer a file is open, the more likely that the opportunity to seize the ideal, cost-efficient outcome will slip away. We will help you design a creative resolution strategy to minimize cycle time and manage costs, resulting in a better client experience, both for you and your insureds. We have the versatility to assemble the appropriate team of lawyers for sophisticated, high-exposure cases, and those that are less so. Regardless of the case’s complexity or potential exposure, our goal remains the same – explore the most efficient, cost-containment solution available, but when necessary, fight relentlessly to achieve the best result at trial.
Being a Field Law client includes many benefits and opportunities. We constantly evaluate and advance our technology infrastructure to ensure our clients take advantage of the most cost-efficient approaches to file management. We also provide regular publications, email bulletins and learning seminars that allow you to stay current on trends in insurance law and dispute resolution, plus casual, off-the-clock discussions and firm community events to help us to get to know you and your business better.
We manage complex insurance matters including:
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
- Disability + Life Insurance
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
MGN Constructors Inc v AXA Pacific Insurance Company, 2018 ABQB 631Arc Line Construction Ltd v Smith Trucking Services (1976) Ltd, 2018 ABQB 448Alberta Motor Association Insurance Company v Aspen Insurance UK Limited, 2018 ABQB 207DECISION Piikani Naton v. Kostic 2017 ABCA 399, ABCA 399HVC Canada Ltd v. EllisDon Construction Services Inc., 2016 ABQB 602HVC Canada Ltd. v. EllisDon Construction Services Inc., 2016 ABQB 105Cranbrook (City) v. Gabriel Construction (Alberta) Ltd., 2014 BCSC 2280MGN Constructors Inc. v. Axa Pacific Insurance Company, 2012 ABQB 561V.A.H. v. Lynch, 2009 ABCA 104, Alberta Court of Appeal Zubick v. Alberta Teachers' Association, 2009 ABCA 136, Alberta Court of Appeal Dhaliwal v. EPSB, 2008 ABQB 429, Alberta Court of Queen's Bench Fullowka v. Royal Oak Ventures Inc., [2008} N.W.T.J. No. 27, Northwest Territories Supreme Court Opal v. Boyd, 2008 ABCA 25, Alberta Court of Appeal Shipanoff v. Landry, 2008 ABQB 212, Alberta Court of Queen's Bench Zubick v. Alberta Teachers' Association, 2008 ABCA 388, Alberta Court of Appeal Zubick v. Alberta Teachers' Association, 2008 ABQB 582, Alberta Court of Queen's Bench Zubick v. Alberta Teachers' Association, 2008 ABQB 241, Alberta Court of Queen's Bench Zubick v. Alberta Teachers' Association, 2008 ABQB 5, Alberta Court of Queen's Benchv InnerSense International Inc. v. University of Alberta, [2007] A.J. No. 270, Alberta Court of Queen's Bench Opal v. Boyd, 2007 ABQB 373, Alberta Court of Queen's Bench Sra v. Zhu, [2007] A.J. No. 706, Alberta Court of Queen's Bench Wainwright (Town) v. G-M Pearson Environmental Management Ltd., [2007] A.J. No. 1083, Alberta Court of Queen's Bench Wainwright (Twon) v. G-M Pearson Environmental Management Services Ltd., [2007] A.J. No. 1083, Alberta Court of Queen's Bench Abramski v. TD Waterhouse Canada Inc., [2006] A.J. No. 191, Alberta Court of Queen's Bench Base v. Hadley, [2006] N.W.T.J. No. 3, Northwest Territories Supreme Court Besler v. Dillabough, 2006 ABCA 232, Alberta Court of Appeal Fullowka v. Royal Oak Ventures Inc., [2006] N.W.T.J. No. 24, Northwest Territories Supreme Court Lastiwka v. TD Waterhouse Investor Services (Canada) Inc., [2006] A.J. No. 925, Alberta Court of Queen's Bench Ms. R. v. Mr. W., [2006] A.J. No. 1609, Alberta Court of Queen's Bench Purba v. Ryan, 2006 ABCA 229, Alberta Court of Appeal Purba v. Ryan, 2006 ABQB 127, Alberta Court of Queen's Bench Weyerhauser Co. v. Jenner (c.o.b. Magic Welding), [2006] A.J. No. 169, Alberta Court of Queen's Bench Fullowka v. Royal Oak Ventures Inc., [2005] N.W.T.J. No. 57, Northwest Territories Supreme Court Fullowka v. Royal Oak Ventures Inc., [2005] N.W.T.J. No. 57, Northwest Territories Supreme Court Henson v. Champion Feed Services Ltd., 2005 ABQB 215, Alberta Court of Queen's Bench Kallal v. Optimum West, Alberta Court of Queen's Bench Lastiwka v. TD Waterhouse Investor Services (Canada) Inc., [2005] A.J. No. 1718, Alberta Court of Queen's Bench Lastiwka v. TD Waterhouse Investor Services (Canada) Inc., [2005] A.J. No. 1717, Alberta Court of Queen's Bench Lastiwka v. TD Waterhouse Investor Services (Canada) Inc., [2005] A.J. No. 1717, Alberta Court of Queen's Bench Tapia v. Harrish, [2005] A.J. No. 1345, Alberta Court of Queen's Bench Base v. Hadley, [2004] N.W.T.J. No. 23, Northwest Territories Supreme Court Condominium Corp. No. 7921945 v. Cochrane, 2004 ABPC 4, Provincial Court of Alberta Fullowka v. Royal Oak Ventures Inc., [2004] N.W.T.J. No. 64, Northwest Territories Supreme Court Lastiwka v. TD Waterhouse Investor Services (Canada) Inc., [2004] A.J. No. 1160, Alberta Court of Queen's Bench Lastiwka v. TD Waterhouse Investor Services (Canada) Inc., [2004] A.J. No. 1160, Alberta Court of Queen's Bench Schoff v. Royal Insurance, 2004 ABCA 180, Alberta Court of Appeal Synod of the Diocese of Edmonton v. Lombard General Insurance Co. of Canada, 2004 ABQB 803, Alberta Court of Queen's Bench Fullowka v. Royal Oak Ventures Inc., [2003] N.W.T.J. No. 48, Northwest Territories Supreme Court Henson v. Champion Feed Services Ltd., 2003 ABPC 204, Provincial Court of Alberta Rockwell v. Klopstra, [2003] A.J. No. 686, Alberta Court of Queen's Bench Adam v. Beaver, [2002] A.J. No. 1437, Alberta Court of Queen's Bench Dacro Industries Ltd. V. Lombard General Insurance Co. of Canada, [2002] A.J. No. 95, Alberta Court of Queen's Bench Dear v. Styre, [2002] A.J. No. 691, Alberta Court of Queen's Bench Lastiwka v. TD Waterhouse Investor Services (Canada) Inc., [2002] A.J. No. 1352, Alberta Court of Queen's Bench Lombard General Insurance Co. of Canada v. Varco Canada Ltd., [2002] A.J. No. 945, Alberta Court of Queen's Bench Medicine Hat (City) v. Continental Casualty Co., [2002] A.J. No. 350, Alberta Court of Queen's Bench Toronto Dominion Bank v. Real Estate Council of Alberta, [2002] A.J. No. 75, Alberta Court of Queen's Bench Williamson v. Best Plumbing & Heating Supplies Ltd., [2002] S.C.C.A. No. 102, Supreme Court of Canada Williamson v. Best Plumbing & Heating Supplies Ltd., [2002] A.J. No. 291, Alberta Court of Appeal Evans v. Rustad, [2001] A.J. No. 1744, Alberta Court of Queen's Bench Sunshine Village Corp. v. Canada (Minister of Environment), [2001] A.J. No. 651, Alberta Court of Queen's Bench Willier v. Lajeunesse, [2001] A.J. No. 1357, Alberta Court of Queen's Bench Wong v. Mejia, [2001] A.J. No. 665, Alberta Court of Queen's Bench Wood Buffalo (Regional Municipality) v. Scottish & York Insurance Co., [2001] A.J. No. 1650, Alberta Court of Queen's Bench Dear v. Styre, [2000] A.J. No. 1334, Alberta Court of Queen's Bench Guinan v. Northwestel Inc., [2000] N.W.T.J. No. 56, Northwest Territories Supreme Court Guinan v. Northwestel Inc., [2000] N.W.T.J. No. 57, Northwest Territories Supreme Court Malik v. Alberta Motor Association Insurance Co., [2000] A.J. No. 1203, Alberta Court of Queen's Bench Ron's Electric Ltd. v. Burke, [2000] A.J. No. 1304, Alberta Provincial Court, Civil Division Ron's Electric Ltd. v. Harder Burke, [2000] A.J. No. 336, Alberta Provincial Court, Civil Division Williamson v. Best Plumbing & Heating Supplies Ltd., [2000] A.J. No. 495, Alberta Court of Queen's Bench Williamson v. Best Plumbing & Heating Supplies Ltd., [2000] A.J. No. 1122, Alberta Court of Queen's Bench Williamson v. Best Plumbing & Heating Supplies Ltd., [2000] A.J. No. 1152, Alberta Court of Queen's Bench Williamson v. Best Plumbing & Heating Supplies Ltd., [2000] A.J. No. 495, Alberta Court of Queen's Bench Baker v. Yacyshen, [1999] A.J. No. 1289, Alberta Court of Queen's Bench Robertson v. BHP diamonds Inc., [1999] N.W.T.J. No. 52, Northwest Territories Supreme Court Shum v. Mitchell, [1999] A.J.No. 1105, Alberta Court of Queen's Bench Stewart v. Fort McPherson (Hamlet), [1999] N.W.T.J. No. 91, Northwest Territories Supreme Court Tanar Industries Ltd. V. Outokumpu Ecoenergy, Inc., [1999] A.J. No. 919, Alberta Court of Queen's Bench Spenrath v. McKenzie, [1998] N.W.T.J. No. 86, Northwest Territories Supreme Court Wild Rose School Division No. 66 v. Bert Pratch Construction Co., 1998 ABQB 831, Alberta Court of Queen's Bench Valic v. Northwest Territories Housing Corp., [1997] N.W.T.J. No. 53, Northwest Territories Supreme Court Check v. Sun Life Assurance Co. of Canada, [1995] A.J. No. 1400, Alberta Court of Queen's Bench Izzard Estate v. Robinson's Trucking, [1994] A.W.T.J. No. 35, Northwest Territories Supreme Court Modern Livestock v. Kansa General Insurance Company, 157 A.R. 167, Alberta Court of Appeal Reid v. Stein, [1994] A.J. No. 875, Alberta Court of Queen's Bench Rohr (Guardian of) v. Hosack, [1991] A.J. No. 1020, Alberta Court of Queen's Bench April 3, 2019 Staying Current with Auto Liability Claims in Alberta Seminars Join Field Law's Jane Freeman and Michael Doerksen for a seminar discussing:
Reserving Rights and Alberta Auto Coverage Defences
An overview of the major types of coverage defences of the auto insurer under Alberta's standard owner's poli... February 2019 Case Summary: R v Ahmed Defence + Indemnity Charges for distracted driving were widened in scope by including cell and smart phones in the definition of “hand held electronic” and “wireless electronic” devices in the Traffic Safety Act.R v Ahmed, 2019 ABQB 13, per Henders... February 2019 Case Summary: Entwhistle v Wells Defence + Indemnity Where a plaintiff’s vehicle is damaged to the point of becoming a constructive total loss due to a defendant’s negligence, the plaintiff was awarded damages for the time, effort and expense of finding a replacement vehicle.
Entwhistle v We... February 2019 Case Summary: Weir-Jones Technical Services Incorporated v Purolator Courier Ltd Defence + Indemnity The Alberta Court of Appeal clarifies the test for summary judgment and dismissal.Weir-Jones Technical Services Incorporated v. Purolator Courier, Purolator Inc. and Purolator Freight, 2019 ABCA 49 per Slatter JA (Fraser CJA, Watson and Strekaf JJ... February 2019 Case Summary: Enterprise Rent-A-Car v Intact Insurance Defence + Indemnity The legislation setting out priorities among insurers in a rental/leased vehicle situation only applies to those polices which provide coverage and the term “listed driver” in an auto policy is not “an insured named in the contract&rd... February 2019 Case Summary: Modisette v. Apple Inc. Defence + Indemnity In the context of a motor vehicle accident where the at-fault driver was distracted by using his cell phone, the claim against Apple Inc. for marketing the cell phone without technology to disable its use while the user is driving was summarily dismiss... February 14, 2019 The Type of Claims that may Arise from Legalization of Cannabis Edibles Canadian Underwriter Erika Carrasco speaks to Canadian Underwriter about cannabis coverage issues. February 2019 Uncertainty Around Burden of Proof for Summary Judgment Resolved Insurance Alert The law of summary judgment in Alberta has recently been in flux regarding the standard of proof required to resolve a dispute summarily: some panels of the Court have held that proof on a balance of probabilities is required, while others have held th... December 2018 Case Summary: Wm Morrison Supermarkets PLC v Various Claimants Defence + Indemnity Employers can be vicariously liable at common law for the actions of a rogue employee who brings about an unauthorized cyber data breach, even where the employee’s motive was to harm the employer and not to injure the third parties whose data is ... December 2018 Case Summary: Williams v Richard Defence + Indemnity Social hosts were denied summary dismissal after a drunken guest got into an accident, injuring the plaintiff, after the guest had first made it home safely. December 2018 Case Summary: Layes v Stevens Defence + Indemnity A $200,000 loss of future income earning capacity award to a 25 year old student able to continue working full time was upheld where she had no settled employment pattern relying on comparator cases, without a mathematical calculation. December 2018 Case Summary: Aviva v Wawanesa Defence + Indemnity An Ontario Court sets out the factors for determining who the “lessee” of a rented/leased vehicle is for the purposes of determining the priority of insurers providing coverage. December 2018 Case Summary: Dion v Security National Insurance Company Defence + Indemnity A claim for diminished value of a vehicle repaired after an accident is not covered under Section C of the Alberta Standard Auto Policy, SPF No. 1. December 2018 Case Summary: Cardinal v Alberta Motor Association Insurance Company Defence + Indemnity The SEF 44 Endorsement is not a standalone policy and exclusions in the underlying policy apply to it such that a claimant passenger of a stolen vehicle is not entitled to benefits if he/she did not know nor ought to have known that the vehicle was sto... November 2018 No Appeal of the Cardinal Decision: SEF 44 Coverage and Automobile Used Without Consent Insurance Alert On November 15, 2018 the Supreme Court of Canada denied an application for leave to appeal the decision of the Alberta Court of Appeal in Cardinal v Alberta Motor Association Insurance Company, 2018 ABCA 69 (Cardinal).In Cardinal, the insurer, AMA, iss... November 2018 Case Summary: Copytrack Pte Ltd. v Wall Defence + Indemnity A British Columbia court has come out with one of the first Canadian decisions directly addressing the enforcement of rights to ownership of cryptocurrency.Copytrack Pte Ltd. v Wall, 2018 BCSC 1709, per Skolrood, J.FACTS AND ISSUES:Copytrack Pte Ltd. (... November 2018 Case Summary: Green v Khattab Defence + Indemnity Summary judgment ordering specific performance of a settlement reached during a binding Judicial Dispute Resolution was upheld, notwithstanding that a consent order or consent judgment had not been signed between the parties.Green v Khattab, 2018 ABQB ... November 2018 Case Summary: Heuring v Smith Defence + Indemnity The Court assessed liability between a Plaintiff (cyclist) who failed to stop at a stop sign and the driver of a vehicle who did not clearly see the cyclist as a result of a “blind spot” created by a pillar in his vehicle and declined to aw... November 2018 Case Summary: Zando v Ali Defence + Indemnity A damage assessment of $175,000 plus $25,000 for punitives for a single instance of sexual assault upon a colleague, involving intercourse, was upheld on appeal. The Court outlined the factors to be taken into account in quantifying sexual assault dama... November 2018 Case Summary: Condominium Corporation No 9312374 v Aviva Insurance Company of Canada Defence + Indemnity The Supreme Court’s decision in the Ledcor case (which held that “resultant damage” arising from faulty workmanship is not excluded by the faulty workmanship exclusion in a builders’ risk policy) was held not to allow for covera... November 2018 Case Summary: Aviva Insurance Company v Intact Insurance Company Defence + Indemnity Where an insurer contributes more than its share to a defence and settlement of a claim vis-à-vis other insurers who are involved, it may seek contribution from the other insurers even where the policies are complementary and not overlapping.Avi... September 25, 2018 Quantifying Personal Injury + Business Loss Claims with Shawn Hemens Seminars Join Field Law and Shawn Hemens, a Chartered Business Valuator specializing in quantifying personal injury and business loss claims, for a seminar discussing:
Identifying the financial documents needed to asses claims where an income loss from a bu... September 2018 Cyber Losses: A Serious Organizational Risk in the Modern World The Lawyer's Daily September 2018 The Best Lawyers in Canada 2019 28 Field Law Lawyers Recognized Field Law is proud to announce that 28 of our lawyers have been included in the 13th edition of The Best Lawyers™ in Canada. These lawyers have been recognized in 17 service areas, resulting in a total of 36 rankings.Among the 28 Field Law l... August 2018 Case Summary: R.C. Heating & Gasfitting Ltd. v The Sovereign General Insurance Company Defence + Indemnity Where past negligence involved in the installation of the system manifested itself in an explosion years later, the “occurrence” or “accident” was held to have occurred at the time of the explosion, not at the time of the neglig... August 2018 Case Summary: Scale Estate v The Cooperators General Insurance Company Defence + Indemnity When an insurer contemplates settling to its policy limits in an auto case, it must take steps to ensure that all potential claims have been accounted for. Where an insurer, knowing of another claim for the same accident, paid its limits in three... August 2018 Case Summary: Greenidge v. Allstate Insurance Company Defence + Indemnity Unlike the situation with litigation independent medical examinations per Rule 5.42, a Section B insurer is entitled to insist that the insured attend an independent medical examination per Section B Special Provision 4, and the examiner is entitled to... August 2018 Case Summary: Woitas v. Tremblay Defence + Indemnity In a chain reaction series of rear end accidents, following vehicles are presumed to be negligent for rear end collisions and the fact that a driver has to stop for an accident in front of him will be no defence. Drivers of vehicles which manage ... August 2018 CRTC Imposes Penalties On Two Companies For Distributing Malware Online Defence + Indemnity Recently, the Canadian federal government publicized anti-spam legislation, generally referred to as “CASL” (An Act to promote the efficiency and adaptability of the Canadian economy by regulating certain activities that discourage reliance... August 2018 Case Summary: Khudabux v. McClary Defence + Indemnity In the case of a crumbling skull plaintiff the Court will apportion responsibility to the different accidents involved where the injuries in question are not indivisible. Khudabux v. McClary, 2018 BCCA 234 per Stromberg-Stein, J.A. [4286]FACTS AND... August 2018 Case Summary: Alberta Human Rights Commission (Director) v. Vegreville Autobody (1933) Ltd. Defence + Indemnity In some cases, service may be accomplished by email (or deemed good and sufficient), including email upon the servee’s counsel.Alberta Human Rights Commission (Director) v. Vegreville Autobody (1933) Ltd., 2018 ABCA 246 [4282]FACTS AND ISSUES:A C... July 2018 Case Summary: Gharbi v. Summit Acceptance Corp. Defence + Indemnity The Alberta Court of Queen’s Bench enumerated the factors to consider in determining whether the provision a dealership’s loaner vehicle to a customer qualifies as a leased/rented vehicle or a mere courtesy loan for the purposes of determin... July 2018 Case Summary: Temple Insurance Company v. Sazwan Defence + Indemnity Where the conduct of the insureds was in issue in the underlying actions and with respect to coverage under the policy, policy limits covered only 5% of a multimillion dollar claim and an acrimonious relationship existed between the insureds and the in... July 2018 Case Summary: Parent v Northbridge General Insurance Corporation Defence + Indemnity Loss of a reasonable opportunity to investigate and defend a claim due to the Insured’s extreme delay in reporting the incident to their Insurer constituted prejudice to the Insurer such that the Judgment granted against the Insured not enforceab... July 2018 Case Summary: Rankin (Rankin’s Garage & Sales) v. J.J. Defence + Indemnity A garage was found not liable for injuries caused by the thief of one of its vehicles because the fact that it was reasonably foreseeable that vehicles might be stolen from its premises does not make it reasonably foreseeable that the stolen vehicle wo... July 2018 Case Summary: Du v. Jameson Bank Defence + Indemnity A bank customer who was defrauded when hackers accessed his email account to instruct a bank to make unauthorized wire transfers was unable to recover his money from the bank, which followed instructions sent to it by email (as it was allowed and requi... July 2018 Case Summary: C. v. Brookfield Homes Defence + Indemnity QUANTUM/DAMAGES ISSUES
A Plaintiff’s claims for psychological and physical injury arising from the discovery of mould in his home (which had been rectified within a few months) ten years in the past were summarily dismissed. Even if his emotio... July 2018 Case Summary: Waissmann v Calgary (City) Defence + Indemnity Whether or not an occurrence report filled out by an employee after an accident, required by the employer’s rules, is privileged depends on the employer’s intention (dominant purpose) in promulgating the rules – a specific intent on t... June 2018 Municipal Minute: Case Comment on McAllister v. Calgary In the McAllister v. Calgary (City), 2018 ABQB 480 Madame Justice Kubik of the Court of Queen’s Bench found the City of Calgary liable under the Occupiers Liability Act for injuries suffered by the Plaintiff Kyle McAllister when he was assaulted ... June 2018 Priority Among Insurers in an Alberta Rental/Leased Vehicle Claim The Six Circles of Hell June 5, 2018 A Primer – Occupational Therapy Seminars Insurance Seminar Join Field Law's Sharon Stefanyk and Occupational Therapist Gillian Bagg for an opportunity to learn from an occupational therapist experienced in providing expert opinion regarding a person’s physical capacities and their ability to particip... May 2018 Minor Injury Regulation Changes Insurance Alert Changes to the Minor Injury Regulation (AR 123.2004) (“MIR”) are expected shortly, which clarify certain misinterpretations of the wording of the MIR to date.Although the wording of the regulation has always made it clear that injuries to m... May 2018 What is the Duty of Care owed by Bailee of a Vehicle to Innocent Third Parties on the Road? Insurance Alert Does a garage owner owe a duty of care to a third party who comes onto the businesses private property, steals a vehicle and is injured in a subsequent motor vehicle accident? The Supreme Court of Canada has ruled that “a business will only owe a... April 2018 Case Summary: Tree-Techol Tree Technology and Research Co. v Via Rail Canada Inc. Defence + Indemnity A. An Insured has no obligation to include an Insurer’s subrogated claim in an action to recover losses in excess of its insurance coverage.Tree-Techol Tree Technology and Research Co. v Via Rail Canada Inc., 2017 ONCA 876 [4266]; aff’g 201... April 2018 Case Summary: Tuffnail et al v Meekes et al Defence + Indemnity B. A claimant is not required to sue all tort-feasors in order to collect under the OCPF 44 Endorsement (and the Alberta SEF 44 Endorsement).
Tuffnail et al v Meekes et al, 2017 ONSC 2894, per H.A. Rady J. [4268]
FACTS AND... April 2018 Case Summary: Oliveira v. Aviva Canada Inc. Defence + Indemnity C. The Ontario Court of Appeal upheld a decision that a hospital insurer owed a duty to defend a hospital employee sued for the privacy tort of inclusion upon seclusion, as such was an “invasion or violation of privacy” or an “invasio... April 2018 Case Summary: Core Ventures Inc v Trio Chute Inc (Aluminum Planet) Defence + Indemnity A. Where the lease specifies that the Landlord is obligated to take out fire insurance, the tenant is presumed to generally from the insurance proceeds (even where the fire is caused by the tenant’s negligence) and clear language in the lease is ... April 2018 Case Summary: Biggar v. Enns Defence + Indemnity B. In rear-end collisions the trailing driver is not always liable; the Court is to consider the factual circumstances in each case: the speed of the trailing vehicle, the distance between the vehicles, the actions of the trailing driver before the eme... April 2018 Case Summary: Stefanyk v Sobeys Capital Incorporated Defence + Indemnity C. A tenant of a shopping centre may be an “occupier” of a sidewalk in front of its leased premises in some circumstances, or owe visitors a common law duty of care regarding same, but it is not negligence to put a bicycle rack at tha... April 2018 Case Summary: Jones v. I.F. Propco Defence + Indemnity A. An Ontario court declined to order a personal injury Plaintiff who had posted pre-accident activities on her public Facebook profile to produce her private profile, even where she planned to call witnesses to testify to the differences between... April 2018 Case Summary: Nasr Hospitality Services Inc. v Intact Insurance Defence + Indemnity A. The Court, applying Ontario’s appropriateness factor under the Limitations Act, 2002, SO 2002, c 24, Schedule B., found the limitations period was did not begin to run until the insurer denied the claim under the insurance policy, sometime aft... April 2018 Case Summary: Glover v. Leaky Defence + Indemnity B. An admission of liability in an action is not a formal admission binding the party making it in a subsequent action relating to the same accident, but is only evidence in the second action to be attributed such weight as the Court decides. Thu... April 2018 Cannabis: Insurance Implications Seminars CICMA/CIAA Education Conference February 2018 Case Summary: Hartley v Security National Insurance Company Defence + Indemnity A. An Ontario plaintiff was held to be able to look to his OPCF 44R insurer to pay his damages in excess of a liability cap in the U.S. state where the accident occurred up to the OPCF 44R limits but not for the plaintiff’s U.S. legal fees.... February 2018 Case Summary: Aviva Insurance Company of Canada v Intact Insurance Company Defence + Indemnity B. The Court held that a duty to defend was triggered by pleadings alleging an escape of fuel oil onto neighbouring property despite a pollution exclusion clause in the policies, because the pleaded facts did not allow a determination if the escape fel... February 2018 Case Summary: Cardinal v Alberta Motor Association Insurance Company Defence + Indemnity C. The SEF 44 Endorsement is not a standalone policy and exclusions in the underlying policy apply to it such that a claimant passenger of a stolen vehicle is entitled to benefits if he/she did not know nor ought to have known that the vehicle was stol... February 2018 Case Summary: Vanderveen v Waterbridge Media Inc. Defence + Indemnity A. Employing a video shot of a person jogging on a public jogging path for a commercial sales-pitch video was found to establish the privacy tort of intrusion upon seclusion. Vanderveen v Waterbridge Media Inc., 2017 CanLII 77435 (Ont.S.C. Small ... February 2018 Case Summary: Stefanyk v Stevens Defence + Indemnity A. A tenant was found to be an “occupier” of its premises and potentially liable when a dog lunged at a party on the adjacent sidewalk, causing her to fall on the basis of allegedly having allowed a condition or activity on its premises to ... February 2018 Case Summary: Stevenson v Thompson Defence + Indemnity A. A Plaintiff was found by the trial judge to have exaggerated her pain levels and to have lied during Questioning and to her health care professionals but was still found at trial to be credible and honest, which resulted in the Plaintiff obtaining a... February 2018 Case Summary: Alberta v Suncor Energy Inc. Defence + Indemnity A. Documents generated for an internal investigation of an accident can be protected by litigation privilege if they were created for the dominant purpose of litigation but that does not mean that every document on the investigation file is privileged ... February 2018 Case Summary: Valard Construction Ltd. v Bird Construction Co. Defence + Indemnity A. Supreme Court of Canada finds obligee/trustee under a Labour and Material Payment Bond breached the fiduciary duty owed to a claimant by failing to disclose existence of the Bond. Valard Construction Ltd. v. Bird Construction Co., 2018 SCC 8, p... January 2018 Understanding Limitations of Liability: Recent Alberta and Canadian Case Law Canadian Institute: Managing Risk in Construction Contracts & Projects Conference December 2017 Through the Scratched Looking Glass: Sattva, Ledcor, Teal and Developments in the Law of Contract Carswell Annual Review of Civil Litigation 2017 December 2017 Case Summary: Middleton v Pankhurst Defence + Indemnity A. In Ontario the Statutory Condition in an auto policy requiring that the driver be “authorized by law” to drive refers to the licensing regime such that breaching driving conditions in a probation order does not render the driver to be un... December 2017 Case Summary: Economical Mutual Insurance Company v Gill Defence + Indemnity B. Where a claim is advanced against a parent in negligence for injury suffered by his child, the family member exclusion clause in the parent’s homeowner’s policy was held to exclude coverage for the parent. Economical Mutual Insuran... December 2017 Case Summary: Co-operators General Insurance Company v. Kane Defence + Indemnity C. Where the policy excludes coverage for intentional acts, allegations of negligence relating to the same claim will not be excluded from coverage if “it is possible that they were not committed with the same intention or state of mind, being to... December 2017 Case Summary: Reeb v. The Guarantee Company of North America Defence + Indemnity D. An insurer-appointed defence counsel will be in conflict of interest if the interests of the insurer and the insured are not in alignment, and in such cases the Court may appoint independent counsel (an amicus curae or Cumis counsel) to defend the i... December 2017 Case Summary: Oliveira v. Aviva Canada Inc. Defence + Indemnity E. A hospital insurer was held to owe a duty to defend a hospital employee sued for the privacy tort of inclusion upon seclusion, as such was an “invasion or violation of privacy” or an “invasion or violation of a right of privacy, wi... December 2017 Case Summary: Hobin v. Enterprise Rent-A-Car Company Defence + Indemnity A. The 2009 amendments to the Traffic Safety Act and the Insurance Act with respect to the liability of a renter, lessor or lender of a vehicle were intended to cap their vicarious liability for the driver’s negligence at $1 million and to make t... December 2017 Case Summary: Larizza v. The Royal Bank of Nova Scotia Defence + Indemnity B. A landlord conducting a credit check on a prospective tenant without their knowledge or consent does not amount to the privacy tort of intrusion upon seclusion, as the Ontario statute authorized a credit check in the circumstances and a reasonable p... December 2017 Case Summary: R v Shah Defence + Indemnity A. After the first reported decision on drones in Canada, the drone operator was found guilty of flying his drone "in a manner hazardous or likely hazardous to aviation safety" under section 602.45 of the Canadian Aviation Regulations as it t... December 2017 Case Summary: Baker v Poucette Defence + Indemnity A. Where a plaintiff is held to suffer a negative loss (i.e. has had a “gain”) under one head of damage, that gain is not to be offset or deducted from another head of damage where the plaintiff has suffered a loss.
Baker v Poucette, 2017 ... November 2017 Sandra Corbett, QC recognized with a Women in Law Leadership (WILL) Award For Leadership in the Profession in Private Practice Sandra Corbett, QC, has won a 2017 Women In Law Leadership (WILL) Award in the area of Leadership in the Profession (Private Practice). The Award recognizes and applauds lawyers in private practice who has shown extraordinary leadership and a commitmen... October 2017 The Brick Warehouse LP v Chubb Insurance Company of Canada Defence + Indemnity Newsletter A. Where an insured’s employee followed an email from a fraudster posing as a vendor to change the electronic payment instructions to an account controlled by the fraudster, coverage was denied under the funds transfer fraud coverage in a crime p... October 2017 Birss v Tien Lung Taekwon-Do Club Defence + Indemnity Newsletter A. The Master allowed a claim for a sports injury to be amended to add breach of fiduciary duty as a cause of action in the teacher-student situation, and held that while sports participants are taken to consent to the risks inherent in the sport, ther... October 2017 Hudye Inc v Rosowsky Defence + Indemnity Newsletter A. Notes prepared for a witness to rely upon to refresh his/her memory prior to a Questioning may not be privileged and, if they are, relying on those notes to testify waives any privilege over the notes. Hudye Inc v Rosowsky, 2016 ABQB 724, per ... October 2017 Bruff-Murphy v Gunawardena Defence + Indemnity Newsletter B. The trial judge was held to have erred in allowing an expert witness, who the judge had reservations about, to testify when said expert was clearly not independent. Judges have a role as gatekeeper to ensure expert witnesses are worthy of being expe... October 2017 Case Summary: Vermilion & District Housing Foundation v Binder Construction Limited Defence + Indemnity Newsletter A. The Alberta Court of Queen’s Bench holds surety liable under a performance bond for consequential damages suffered by an obligee as result of defaulting contractor. Vermilion & District Housing Foundation v Binder Construction Limite... August 2017 Defence + Indemnity - August 2017 August 2017 The Best Lawyers in Canada 2018 25 Field Law Lawyers Recognized
25 Lawyers from Field Law Recognized in The Best Lawyers™ in Canada 2018
Field Law is pleased to announce that 25 lawyers have been included in the 12th Edition of The Best Lawyers™ in Canada. Three of these lawyers are new additions a... August 2017 Case Summary: Funk v. Wawanesa Mutual Insurance Company Defence + Indemnity The Court may refuse to apply an insurance policy provision where it would lead to an unjust result in the circumstances, per s. 545(1) of the Insurance Act or pursuant to the Court’s ability to relieve against forfeiture, per the Judicature Act,... August 2017 Knibb v. Foran Defence + Indemnity The case against a baseball team operating a beer tent at a tournament in commercial host liquor liability was dismissed after a summary trial despite the lack of a system to monitor patron consumption, because the evidence did not establish that the t... August 2017 Bumstead v. Dufresne Defence + Indemnity The Court of Appeal upheld a trial judgment based on significant plaintiff credibility issues awarding less than $300,000 in the face of a $2,000,000 claim. Bumstead v. Dufresne, 2017 ABCA 122 [4236]I. FACTS AND ISSUES
This judgement inv... August 2017 Biancaniello v. DMCT LLP Defence + Indemnity Litigation Releases can be wide enough to preclude future claims between the parties that were unknown and unanticipated when the Release was executed. Biancaniello v. DMCT LLP, 2017 ONCA 386, per Feldman, J.A. [4235]I. FACTS AND ISSUES
... August 2017 Nemchin v. Green Defence + Indemnity A court held that the Defence was precluded from tendering social media evidence relating to the Plaintiff and relying on it at trial, notwithstanding that the Plaintiff may have been obligated to disclosure it herself, where the Defendant agreed to a ... February 2017 Defence + Indemnity - February 2017 February 2017 The MIR and the Charter January 2017 CPP Disability Benefits: To Deduct or Not to Deduct December 2016 Defence + Indemnity - December 2016 October 2016 Defence + Indemnity - October 2016 October 2016 Civil Litigation in Alberta - Surprises, Secrets and Strategies Presentations September 2016 Long Lasting and Difficult to Eradicate: An Update on General Damages Awards for Chronic Pain in Alberta August 2016 Defence + Indemnity - August 2016 July 2016 Alberta Government Updating 2004 Auto Insurance Reforms Insurance Alert The Alberta government has announced that it is in the process of updating the regulations involved in the 2004 auto insurance reform, namely the Minor Injury Regulation, Alta Reg 123/2004Íž the Diagnostic and Treatment Protocols Reg... July 2016 Police Access to Accused Statements to the Insurer Canadian Bar Association July 2016 If Your Expert Doesn’t Know the Product he is Testifying on, You’re Gonna Have a Bad Time Insurance Alert Most will remember the case McDougall v. Black & Decker Canada Inc. as being the leading Alberta case on the issue of spoliation. A fire occurred which burned down the Plaintiffs' house. The Fire Department who initially inv... June 2016 Defence + Indemnity - June 2016 June 2016 Case Summary: HOOPP Realty Inc. v. The Guarantee Company of North America Defence + Indemnity Newsletter Obligee's claim against surety can survive despite Obligee's claim against principal being unenforceable as a result of wording of completion agreement. May 2016 Keeping Your Cards Close To Your Vest May 2016 Keeping Your Cards Close to Your Vest - Protecting Confidentiality for Statements May 2016 Bad Faith and Disability Insurance: Update, Traps and Tips May 2016 Keeping Your Cards Close to Your Vest - Protecting Confidentiality for Statements April 2016 Defence + Indemnity - April 2016 April 2016 Social Networking in Litigation March 2016 When the Police Come Knocking: Police Access to Airbag Control Module Data and the Insured’s Statements March 2016 Dempsey v. Bagley, 2016 ABQB 124 - Lessors of Vehicles Still Vulnerable Under Workers Compensation Act Insurance Alert Dempsey v. Bagley, 2016 ABQB 124 - Lessors of Vehicles Still Vulnerable Under Workers Compensation Act
There were two motor vehicle accidents in the summer of 2006. The plaintiffs and the defendants involved in the accidents were ... March 2016 When the Police Come Knocking: Police Access to Airbag Control Module Data and the Insured’s Statements March 2016 When the Police Come Knocking: Police Access to Airbag Control Module Data and the Insured’s Statements February 2016 Defence + Indemnity - February 2016 February 2016 River Deep, Deductible High: Home Owners and Condo Insurance February 2016 Stop - Before You Break New Laws February 2016 Everyone is Watching - Social Media and Litigation January 2016 Stop - Before You Break New Laws June 2016 Accident Investigations November 2015 Defence + Indemnity - November 2015 October 2015 Police and Adjuster Statements – Admissible or Not? Insurance Alert The Alberta Court of Appeal in the recent case of R. v. Porter, 2015 ABCA 279, has concluded that neither a statement made to the police pursuant to the Traffic Safety Act section 71, nor a statement provided to an insurance adjuste... October 2015 CGL Policies - Basic Information and Current Trends June 2015 Mediation: Putting the Resolution of Claims Back in the Hands of the Parties June 2015 Dropping Dead: Rule 4.33 May 2015 Diminished Value Hits a Wall April 2015 Changes to Court Fees in Alberta Insurance Alert The Budget delivered by the Alberta Government on March 26, 2015 announced an increase in court filing fees. The new fee schedule will be in effect commencing May 1, 2015.
Some of the fee schedules coming from the Court of Queen’s Benc... March 2015 Minor Settlements - Beware of the Pitfalls September 2015 Social Networking in Litigation December 2014 The Alberta Court of Appeal Expands the Requirements for Describing Privileged Records in an Affidavit of Records November 2014 Social Networking in Litigation October 2014 Accelerated Depreciation/Diminished Value October 2014 Catastrophic Injuries September 2014 Litigating Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder Claims July 2014 Provincial Court Expected to Increase Financial Limits May 2014 Changing the Landscape: The Trajectory of Diminished Value Claims in Alberta March 2014 New Cases in Negligent Supervision March 2014 Bad Faith Claims: Awareness and Prevention in Claims Handling January 2014 Paving The Way Forward: Automobile Claims and Diminished Value The long awaited King et al v. Satchwell et al., 2013 ABPC 358, decision of the Honourable Judge Skitsko on diminished value has been released. This decision, argued by Field Law’s own Alex Yiu, has helped to clarify several legal issues bei... January 2014 Legislative Changes in 2013 January 2014 Managing Difficult Diagnoses - Chronic Pain November 2013 Insurance Law Topics of Interest: Diminished Value October 2013 Cyber Liability: How I learned to Stop Worrying and Love the Internet (but not too much) October 2013 Cyber Liability: How I learned to Stop Worrying and Love the Internet (but not too much) October 2013 Cyber Liability: How I learned to Stop Worrying and Love the Internet (but not too much) September 2013 Indecent Exposure: Privilege as Applied to Claims Adjusting September 2013 Indecent Exposure: Privilege as Applied to Claims Adjusting July 2013 Alberta Court Wipes Out Privilege Over Insured Statements To Adjuster July 2013 Advanced Payments by Automobile Insurers July 2013 Auto Claims in Alberta: Recent Trends Relating to the Rules of Court and Minor Injury Regulation June 2013 No One Needs to Know: The Pierringer Agreement Settlement Amount Need Not Be Disclosed In the recent Supreme Court of Canada decision of Sable Offshore Energy Inc. v. Ameron International, 2013 SCC 37, Sable Offshore Energy sued multiple suppliers and contractors who supplied paint and completed surface preparations that w... May 2013 From Open to Business to Screaming Halt - How to Quantify Downtime Claims May 2013 Joint and Several Liability April 2013 Housekeeping Damages and Dealing with Difficult Counsel April 2013 Occupier Liability Trends in Alberta April 2013 Housekeeping Damages and Dealing with Difficult Counsel March 2013 Dealing with Difficult Counsel March 2013 Use of Expert Witnesses at Trial March 2013 Video Killed the IME Star - The Effect of the New Rules of Court on Defence IMEs March 2013 A Nightmare Scenario: Psychological Injuries and Assessment of Damages (FULL) February 2013 Indemnity & Insurance Clauses in Litigation February 2013 Indemnity & Insurance Clauses in Litigation December 2012 Insurance Law Issues October 2012 What to Do When a Major Fire Loss Occurs October 2012 Up in Flames...How to Prevent Spoliation in a Fire Loss October 2012 Up in Flames...How to Prevent Spoliation in a Fire Loss September 2012 Rasouli in the SCC: Redrawing the legal map for end-of-life decision making July 2012 If a Tree Falls in Quebec, Can Anybody Sue? June 2012 Material Contribution is the Unicorn of Canadian Tort Law June 2012 Annapolis County District School Board v. Marshall, 2012 SCC 27 June 2012 Insurance Law Update May 2012 Costs and Disbursements - An Overview May 2012 Minor Injury Regulations May 2012 Alberta Insurance Amendment Act April 2012 Dealing with Difficult Counsel April 2012 Insurance Law Update April 2012 Canadian Health Care System April 2012 How to Deal With Difficult Counsel March 2012 One Court, Two Processes: The Interplay of Civil and Criminal Proceedings March 2012 The Sprains and Strains Stay Mainly a Big Pain: The Minor Injury Regulation and Sparrowhawk February 2012 Alberta Rules of Court February 2012 Western Canadian Check Up on Auto Reform January 2012 Sparrowhawk v. Zapoltinsky December 2011 Minor Injury Regulations November 2001 The Good, The Bad and the Ugly: Recent Developments Regarding The Duty to Defend October 2011 Minor Injury Regulations October 2011 Condominium Losses - Working With Multiple Policies and Reluctant Property Managers September 2011 Alberta Workers' Compensation Legislation September 2011 TMJ and the Minor Injury Regulation September 2011 TMJ and the Minor Injury Regulation September 2011 Alberta Workers' Compensation Legislation August 2011 Summary Judgment and the "CAP" - A New Decision Regarding the Minor Injury Regulation August 2011 Conduct of a Provincial Court Trial July 2011 Canadian Health Care System May 2011 Social/Commercial Host Issues May 2011 Alberta Rules of Court March 2011 Cyber Liability - Defamation February 2011 The Minor Injury Cap February 2011 Host Liquor Liability February 2011 Alberta Rules of Court February 2011 The Minor Injury Cap February 2011 Moderator: Litigation, Mitigation and Strategies In Between November 2010 New Rules of Court November 2010 A New, and Wider, Approach to Duty of Care, Fullowka v. Pinkerton's of Canada Ltd. 2010 SCC 5 November 2010 New Rules of Court October 2010 Witness Statements, Traps and Tips for Adjusters September 2010 Alberta's Minor Injury Regulation September 2010 Indemnity and Insurance Clauses in Litigation September 2010 Fire Investigation Course August 2010 Sprains, Strains and Automobiles June 2010 Sprains, Strains and Automobiles June 2010 Surveillance Evidence: Instruction, Disclosure & Use at Trial May 2010 Windows on the World: Social Networking Sites and the Law May 2010 Spoliation, Privacy, Privilege April 2010 Controversial Proposed Independent Medical Examination Rule Likely To Be Amended April 2010 Minor Injury Regulation April 2010 Windows on the World: Social Networking Sites and the Law April 2010 Minor Injury Regulation February 2010 Fullowka v. Pinkerton's of Canada Ltd. February 2010 Sprains, Strains and Automobiles - The Cap is Here to Stay February 2010 Sprains, Strains and Automobiles - The Cap is Here to Stay February 2010 Sprains, Strains and Automobiles - The Cap is Here to Stay November 2009 Social Networking Sites November 2009 Privacy and Surveillance November 2009 Privacy and Surveillance October 22, 2009 Host Liquor Liability October 2009 Impaired Driving Issues in Auto Insurance October 2009 Impaired Driving Issues in Auto Insurance September 2009 Surveillance, Privacy, Spoliation and Privilege September 2009 Surveillance, Privacy, Spoliation and Privilege September 2009 Surveillance, Privacy, Spoliation and Privilege September 2009 Surveillance, Privacy, Spoliation and Privilege September 2009 10 New Rules - Rules of Interest to Examiners in the Final Draft of the New Rules of Court September 2009 Insurance Amendment Acts B.C. and Alberta June 2009 The Alberta Minor Injury Cap Webinar May 2009 Three Sheets to the Wind: Host Liquor Liability in Canada April 2009 Alberta and B.C. Insurance Amendment Acts March 2009 Alberta Insurance Amendment Act, 2008 February 2009 Insurance 2008 Year in Review February 2009 "Indecent Exposure": Privilege as Applied to Claims Adjusting January 2009 Insurance 2008 Year in Review January 2009 Discovery Preparation from a Defence Perspective January 2009 2008 Year in Review November 2008 Use & Operation of a Motor Vehicle November 2008 Use of Juries in Civil Litigation September 2008 Your Insured Has Been Sued for a Loss Intentionally Caused by Someone Else, What is Your Exposure? September 2008 Life After the Cap (Minor Injury Regulation) August 2008 Use & Operation of a Motor Vehicle June 2008 Minor Injury Cap June 2008 Blurring of the Line Between "Natural Causes" and "Accident" June 2008 "Use or Operation of an Automobile" After Vytlingam and Herbison April 2008 The Alberta Minor Injury Regulation: Where the Heck are We Going? April 2008 Life of a Fire File March 2008 Life After the Cap March 2008 "Use or Operation of an Automobile" After Vytlingam and Herbison 2008 Bill 11, Insurance Amendment Act 2008 2008 Bill 11, Insurance Amendment Act 2008 Janaury 2008 Minor Injury Regulation September 2007 The Minor Injury Cap Trial June 2007 Liability Issues June 2007 Morrow and Pedersen: Arguments in the Minor Injury Cap Challenge June 2007 Morrow and Pedersen: Arguments in the Minor Injury Cap Challenge June 2007 Quantum/Damages Issues March 2007 Maternal Tort Liability February 2007 Various Insurance Topics February 2007 Limitations Act; Occupier's Liability; Charter Challenge to the MIR February 2007 Standardizing Limitation Periods for Actions on Insurance Contracts: Where Are We? 2007 Morrow and Pedersen: Arguments Presented at the Minor Injury Cap Challenge 2007 Minor Injury Cap - Argument is the Constitutional Challenge December 2006 Minor Injury Cap October 2006 Lynne v. Taylor: A New Standard of Appellate Review in Alberta October 2006 Minor Injury Cap September 2006 Public Safety: Responsibilities of the Parking Lot Owner, Operator and the Public March 2006 The MIR and the Charter 2006 Minor Injury Cap - Implementation November 2005 Consent to Operate a Motor Vehicle -Liability and Coverage November 2005 Questionable Coverage - Non-Waivers and Reservations of Rights October 2005 Update on Liability Defences: Seatbelts, Intoxication, Left Hand Turns & Other Miscellaneous Examples of Contributory Negligence in Motor Vehicle Accident Personal Injury Cases April 2005 The Trilogy and the Charter February 2005 Limitations Act May 2004 The Manufacturer's Duty to Warn: I Wouldn't Eat That If I Were You! January 2004 Construction Bonding and Insurance Update December 2003 Various Insurance Topics November 2003 Blasts From The Past: Discoverability Under Alberta's New Limitations Act September 2003 Surveillance Evidence: Instruction, Disclosure & Use at Trial May 2003 Controlled & Controllable: Practice Tips in Bad Faith Claims April 2003 Surveillance Evidence: Instruction, Disclosure & Use at Trial March 2003 Apportionment of Liability Among Concurrent Tort-Feasors and The Seat Belt Defence in Alberta January 2003 Privilege Issues in Insurance Bad Faith Actions, Production of Documents November 2002 Surveillance Evidence: Instruction, Disclosure & Use at Trial February 2002 The Good, The Bad and the Ugly: Recent Developments Regarding The Duty to Defend March 2001 Social Host Liability in the Wake of Hunt v. Sutton Group 2001 Civil Litigation Process June 2000 Automobile Insurance Issues Relating to Impaired Driving 2000 Civil Litigation Process November 1999 Update on Occupiers' Liability September 1999 Traumatic Brain Injury: Recent Trends in Alberta August 1999 Basic Principles Regarding The Duty to Defend 1999 Joint and Several Tort Feasors, Traps for the Unwary 1995-Present Presentations for insurer clients on a variety of topics Periodically Various courses on Civil Litigation process & Insurance Law |
|
|